CO129-115 - Sir MacDonnell - 1866 [9-10] — Page 277

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

276

Your Memorialists again bring to your Lordship's notice that while they object to the Principle of the proposed Tax, and earnestly deprecate the initiation of such a radical change in the Policy which has hitherto, in their opinion, so wisely been followed here in all matters relating to Revenue, they are strongly impressed with the belief that no increased taxation whatever is necessary and that the existing Revenue will be found ample to meet any expenditure that is really called for or required in the Colony. Representing, as they assert themselves to represent, every class in the Community (Government Servants excepted,) they sincerely believe that it will be far better in the interests of the Colony, and its residents of all walks in life, that, in the event of any increased taxation becoming actually necessary, it should be raised, as hitherto, by direct local taxation, than by incurring, what your Memorialists believe to be, a certain risk of causing the withdrawal, or diminution, of that Trade, upon which alone the Colony exists, and of diverting from it that enormous capital, which is at present attracted here for investment or employment.

Your Memorialists might, and can, controvert many of the statements and conclusions appearing in His Excellency's Reply, but their object is not to make your Lordship the arbiter in a controversy between the Governor and the Colonists, but to endeavour to impress upon your Lordship's mind that though they do not object to pay all necessary expenditure, they are sincere in their conviction that no increase of taxation is at present called for and, even if it be, that this mode of raising the money will be prejudicial to their interests and those of the Colony at large.

Your Memorialists therefore humbly beg your Lordship to advise Her Most Gracious Majesty to refuse the Royal Confirmation to the Stamp Ordinance.

Victoria

Hong Kong

1st October 1866.

Edit History

2026-05-19 11:50:56 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
276 Your Memorialists again bring to your Lordship's notice that while they object to the Principle of the proposed Tax, and earnestly deprecate the initiation of such a radical change in the Policy which has hitherto, in their opinion, so wisely been followed here in all matters relating to Revenue, they are strongly impressed with the belief that no increased taxation whatever is necessary and that the existing Revenue will be found ample to meet any expenditure that is really called for or required in the Colony. Representing, as they assert themselves to represent, every class in the Community (Government Servants excepted,) they sincerely believe that it will be far better in the interests of the Colony, and its residents of all walks in life, that, in the event of any increased taxation becoming actually necessary, it should be raised, as hitherto, by direct local taxation, than by incurring, what your Memorialists believe to be, a certain risk of causing the withdrawal, or diminution, of that Trade, upon which alone the Colony exists, and of diverting from it that enormous capital, which is at present attracted here for investment or employment. Your Memorialists might, and can, controvert many of the statements and conclusions appearing in His Excellency's Reply, but their object is not to make your Lordship the arbiter in a controversy between the Governor and the Colonists, but to endeavour to impress upon your Lordship's mind that though they do not object to pay all necessary expenditure, they are sincere in their conviction that no increase of taxation is at present called for and, even if it be, that this mode of raising the money will be prejudicial to their interests and those of the Colony at large. Your Memorialists therefore humbly beg your Lordship to advise Her Most Gracious Majesty to refuse the Royal Confirmation to the Stamp Ordinance. Victoria Hong Kong 1st October 1866.
Baseline (Original)
276 Your Memorialists again bring to your Lordship's notice that while they object to the Principle of the proposed Tax, and carnestly deprecate the initiation of such a radical change in the Policy which has hitherto, in their opinion, su wisely been followed here in all matters relating to Revenue, they are strongly impressed with the belief that no increased taxation whatever is necessary and that the existing Revenue will be found ample to meet any expenditure that is really called for or required in the Colony. Representing, as they assert themselves to represent, every class in the Community (Government Servants excepted,) they sincerely believe that it will be far better in the interests of the Colony, and its residents of all walks in life, that, in the event of any increased taxation becoming actually necessary, it should be raised, as hitherto, by direct local taxation, than by incurring, what your Memorialists believe to be, a certain risk of causing the withdrawal, or diminution, of that Trade, upon which alone the Colony exists, and of diverting from it that enormous capital, which is at present attracted here for investment or employment. Your Memorialists might, and can, controvert many of the statements and conclusions appearing in His Excellency's Reply, but their object is not to make your Lordship the arbiter in a controversy between the Governor and the Colonists, but to endeavour to impress upon your Lordship's mind that though they do not object to pay all necessary expenditure, they are sincere in their conviction that no increase of taxation is at present called for and, even if it be, that this mode of raising the money will be prejudicial to their interests and those of the Colony at large. Your Memorialists therefore humbly beg your Lordship to advise Her Most Gracious Majesty to refuse the Royal Confirmation to the Stamp Ordinance. Victorie له 1/4 Hong Kong th. October 1866.
2026-05-19 11:50:56 · Baseline
View content

276

Your Memorialists again bring to your Lordship's notice that while they object to the Principle of the proposed Tax, and carnestly deprecate the initiation of such a radical change in the Policy which has hitherto, in their opinion, su wisely been followed here in all matters relating to Revenue, they are strongly impressed with the belief that no increased taxation whatever is necessary and that the existing Revenue will be found ample to meet any expenditure that is really called for or required in the Colony. Representing, as they assert themselves to represent, every class in the Community (Government Servants excepted,) they sincerely believe that it will be far better in the interests of the Colony, and its residents of all walks in life, that, in the event of any increased taxation becoming actually necessary, it should be raised, as hitherto, by direct local taxation, than by incurring, what your Memorialists believe to be, a certain risk of causing the withdrawal, or diminution, of that Trade, upon which alone the Colony exists, and of diverting from it that enormous capital, which is at present attracted here for investment or employment.

Your Memorialists might, and can, controvert many of the statements and conclusions appearing in His Excellency's Reply, but their object is not to make your Lordship the arbiter in a controversy between the Governor and the Colonists, but to endeavour to impress upon your Lordship's mind that though they do not object to pay all necessary expenditure, they are sincere in their conviction that no increase of taxation is at present called for and, even if it be, that this mode of raising the money will be prejudicial to their interests and those of the Colony at large.

Your Memorialists therefore humbly beg your Lordship to advise Her Most Gracious Majesty to refuse the Royal Confirmation to the Stamp Ordinance.

Victorie

له

1/4

Hong Kong

th. October 1866.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.